Showing posts with label Development. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Development. Show all posts

Saturday, May 28, 2011

Exponential Growth and Trends

Two trends started at roughly similar times and fed on each other: the dawn of industrialization and the beginning of formalized pursuit of scientific knowledge. Not only these two trends fed on each other, they were also propelled by an ever faster internal dynamic which in turn fed into the interactions of both. This means that both the process of industrialization and the increase in scientific knowledge are on an exponential curve. Both started slowly and then rapidly increased. Thus we see that the time taken for a scientific discovery to make its way into the classroom is becoming shorter and shorter. Similarly the time taken for a product or process or service to move from the lab into the hands of consumers is also becoming shorter and shorter. This is a blistering pace which is rapidly kicking up in gear as the effects of exponential growth kick in.

Where will this take us? At this point it is hard to say. The past is no longer a guide to the future and indeed has not been so for over 50 years. Each new discovery and technology has had enormous repercussions that have in some fashion radically broken from the past. The light bulb, for example, has enabled us to carry forward daytime activities well into the night. Not only that, it has encouraged new forms of activities and businesses that simply were not possible before. Night clubs are an example. No one will dance late into the night in candle light on a regular basis. High rise buildings are dark, dingy places without the lighting made possible by the light bulb. Without it, the number of high rise building that exist would be much lower. This has obvious repercussions for businesses and individuals.

The light bulb in turn depends on the reliable generation of electricity which requires an understanding and theory of elctro-magnetism. Thus a scientific discovery holds the key to an invention that other inventions and forms in turn depend on. A good example is computers. These machines have revolutionized business and personal interactions. Email for example is an integral part of the lives of large numbers of people. Email cannot exist without computers.

The TV is another example. Coupled with the light bulb, it made possible a new form of entertainment and information dissemination. Before the TV, people made their own entertainment which was essentially local. Now a vast industry exists for the sole purpose of entertainment. A new form of story telling has been invented that is immediate and compelling. Previously, information was also harder to disseminate. Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth would not be possible without the kind of mass dissemination that TV offers.

Airplanes have woven a web around the world that has made travel cheap and convenient. Not only that, it has made possible new types of businesses specially in perishable products. There is a thriving export market of flowers from African countries into Europe and the US. This is a type of business that is impossible without airplanes; flowers are simply too perishable.

As these few examples show, over the last 50 years or so, new discoveries and inventions have ever rapidly made the journey from discovery to the class room to the market. Each has caused a disruption in the fabric of our lives. Their collective impact has been such that our current activities and the things that we take for granted would have seemed incomprehensible and magical to our ancestors living just a 100 years ago.

What will our lives be like 50 years from now? What kinds of activities will we be engaged in? What will be our concerns? These and similar questions are pondered upon by futurologists. The scenarios they conjure are fascinating and often illuminating. Their analysis however has a fundamental problem. We tend to project the present into the future. We identify existing trends and project them forward. No matter how radically different the analysis may seem, it is at its heart a projection of current trends into the future. However, if the recent past should teach us anything it is this: the future is going to be completely and unexpectedly different. New discoveries can easily and very quickly stop current trends in their tracks and kick-start new ones. It is impossible to predict what these new discoveries will be like. What we can be sure of is that there will be big disruptions in our lives and possibilities will exist that we cannot even imagine today.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Thursday, May 26, 2011

Interconnections

The world is holistic. There is an interconnectedness amongst all the systems that operate within it regardless of whether the system in question is natural or man-made. Changes in one area have often large repercussions in other areas that on the outside seem unrelated. An example of this is the current problem of the invasion of non-native species in many areas. Plants and animals introduced into ecosystems in order to control a problem or for aesthetic reasons have become major pests which require expensive and laborious methods to control. The problem is that we tend to treat each system as being isolated with little if any connections to other systems. Doing this simplification has generally served us well in a narrow sense otherwise the problem of analysis, design, construction and operation of said system otherwise doing so becomes too complicated.

Over time, we are slowly realizing the complications that arise from the interconnected nature of the world. Consider some examples. DDT was touted as a miracle pesticide when it was introduced. Its ability to kill off vermin was remarkable. Unfortunately, its ability to kill off other species, specially birds, was also remarkable. The slow disappearance of these species started having knock on effects that multiplied over time. Solving one narrow problem to the exclusion of other effects led to the creation of new problems that required solutions. Another example. CFCs were the solution to the problem of finding a stable refrigerant for use in fridges and freezers. Ultimately it was realized that these molecules were responsible for the thinning of the earth's protective ozone layer and in fact created the ozone hole over the Antarctic. Again not having a holistic view led to severe problems later on.

Consider a man-made repercussion. Why have a large number of Mexicans flocked into the US in recent times? Part of the answer is that these people were displaced from their farms where they used to grow corn. Why did this happen? Subsidized corn from the US flooded the Mexican market after NAFTA dropped trade barriers between Canada, US and Mexico. The price was so low that the Mexican farmer could not compete. Notice the connections. Farming subsidies in the US are evaluated on the basis of their effects on American farmers. NAFTA was supposed to bring the benefits of trade to all the signatory countries. The farming subsidies and NAFTA ended up displacing poor Mexican farmers from their lands. This led to an immigration problem in the US.

These are just some examples amongst many such. These were grand experiments that were carried out in real time. Even today, such experiments are still being carried out. Genetically modified (GM) crops are all the rage today. They have definite benefits. The seeds produce better crop that resists pests more effectively. What is unknown right now is what effect the interaction of these new crops with the rest of the natural world will have. Do not believe reassurances that there will be no effect. There will be an effect or (more likely) effects. What is unknown at this point is precisely what these will be like.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Friday, May 20, 2011

Connections

The future is made of and affected by decisions made in the present just as the present is a product of decisions made in the past. Nothing happens in a vacuum. There is always a context within which events and trends occur. These decisions are made at an individual level as well as at a collective, usually subconscious level. Till now, the present has always been understandable in the context of the past. All the major trends and events to-date can be traced and understood via events and decisions in the past. Events, trends, technologies are often connected in surprising ways.

For example the profession of a social media marketer was simply not possible before the rise of social media sites like Facebook and 4Square. These sites in turn depended on both the widespread availability of the Internet and the mass roll-out of high speed connectivity. This widespread availability of the Internet in turn depended on creation and availability of the appropriate networking technology which needed the development of the appropriate protocols so that different devices could communicate with each other. All of this was driven by the desire of the Pentagon to create a robust communications network that could withstand a full scale nuclear attack. However this desire was necessitated by the Cold War and the development of nuclear weapons; the latter in turn had been developed as a result of World War II when it was feared that the Nazi Germans were on the verge of creating them. So we can clearly see the connections between a modern profession (social media marketing) and seemingly disparate events and decisions made in the past.

The interesting things about the connected nature of the world and how it develops is that no one can predict how technological change will proceed and since that is not possible, it is also not possible to predict the future shape of society since social developments are heavily affected by and in turn themselves affect technological change. For example, in the early 2000s, no one was concerned about the privacy impact of social media simply because said media did not exist. Now, there is discussion about how Facebook will impact and drive social change specially among a generation that has grown up with it. Five years from now, we may well be discussing the impact of some technology that is no one is aware about today. Decisions are made today without knowledge of what the ultimate impact will be. Incidentally, this aspect has been explored in a wonderful BBC series called Connections which highlights the surprising connections between developments in the past and the development of modern technology.

As the series also highlights, there is a corollary to a connected world. Over time, the number and nature of connections will deepen as disparate developments take place and start to be used in other contexts and in ways never anticipated by the original developers. This increasing interconnectedness will in turn drive this process further and faster. As a result, the pace of change will quicken over time and in fact this is what can be observed as well: the pace of change has increased dramatically over time, specially in the last 100 years. What is more, there is no indication that this pace is slackening. Infact, it is accelerating. This has profound implications for social and personal developments and this brings us straight to the concept of the Singularity in the human context (which will be the subject of a later post).
Enhanced by Zemanta

Thursday, April 7, 2011

The Paradox of Development

Human history has been a story of connections. Over the entire course of history, people have forged connections with others. Initially starting with immediate neighbors and then moving on further and further afield. Sometimes the connections made were peaceful, sometimes not. The unequal distribution of resources in the world led to the development of trade which in turn led to further and deeper connections being made. These ever closer connections are an important aspect of development. This process of forging connections was slow but over the very long term steady despite setbacks like collapse of empires (the Roman Empire being a prominent example) and the occasional appearance of devastating diseases like the Black Plague. Industrialization vastly accelerated this process. It is as though the accelerator has been jammed down hard.

Industrialization enabled two very important developments. It lowered transportation cost for all sorts of products (including people) and it lowered communication cost between different regions of the world. Furthermore, it did this while vastly accelerating both processes at the same time. So goods could be transported further and faster and at the same time communication between different regions became more and more in real time.

Today we are all linked together in a vast network spanning the globe. All kinds of goods are routinely ordered from around the world for sale or consumption elsewhere. Families which used to be clustered in a village are now scattered all across. No one is surprised if say a brother is living in one country while a sister may be married and settled in another and the parents live in a third. Again we call this development. Opportunities used to be local. Now they are global. The biggest beneficiaries are corporations. The process of development has resulted in a globalization in which corporations now straddle the world. Unlike most previous entities, these giants have operations in different parts of the world. For example design may be done in the USA, while manufacturing is handled by China, market research may be done from India while the supply chain may be coordinated from the UK. The world of today is a complex interlocking structure which can smoothly transfer goods and services in different stages to different parts of the world at ever lower costs. This is a sophisticated, complicated structure with a unique elegance and beauty. All of this being accomplished without the aid of any central agency.

However, there is a paradox embedded in the heart of this structure. As this structure has become more global and more closely linked (which is an ongoing process), it has also become more fragile. As we have become more dependent on this system of connections, we have also become more vulnerable. The interesting thing is that the more dependent we are on this system, the more vulnerable we are. A shock administered to one part is felt in other parts and other areas of the system. Take Japan. A massive earthquake is followed by a massive tsunami. Large areas are devastated. There is major property damage and unfortunately also major loss of life. A terrible tragedy for the Japanese people. But the fallout from this event is felt in other parts of the world. Suddenly there is a recognition that Japan needs to rebuild. For that it will need money and is very likely to liquidate assets held abroad in order to finance reconstruction. Japan is also a major holder of US treasury bonds. What will happen to the US economy and the value of the US dollar if it starts selling large quantities of these? Many American companies, specially electronics ones, source material from Japan. Now these are heavily affected. Are there alternate suppliers with enough spare capacity to take up this lost production? If they do, how quickly can they gear up production? Fragility. An event in one part of the world is shaking other parts. Another example: Libya. Inspired by the events of Tunisia and Egypt, the Libyans launch their own protest against Muammar Gaddafi's regime. Unlike the other countries, Gaddafi strikes back hard and the country descends into a civil war. Libya however is a large oil producer. All of a sudden this capacity goes offline as far as the rest of the world is concerned. What happens next? Oil prices spike up. Again an event in one part of the world starts shaking up other areas. Fragility.

On a smaller scale, the fragility of the modern world can be seen in our cities. Modern cities are miracles of organization mostly unplanned. Our cities contain huge number of people living cheek by jowl. Vast quantities of different kinds of food and water need to be shipped in daily and distributed efficiently. Equally vast quantities of waste material need to be disposed of again on a daily basis. Cities are major centers of production and provide services essential for the smooth functioning of a modern economy. As an example, America's economic growth would be severely impaired if cities like New York, Chicago, Los Angeles and San Francisco were to become dysfunctional. Cities are a sophisticated and thus a fragile system. What would happen if say a major earthquake were to cut off road and rail links and render airports unusable so that food supplies into the city are severely curtailed? People living in modern, developed cities are dependent on the smooth and timely functioning of the overall system. If it gets disrupted in a major way, starvation is a distinct possibility. Hungry people are not quiet people and so a breakdown of law and order would be very much on the cards. Again, more sophisticated the system, more fragile it is.

If developed countries with their highly sophisticated systems are so fragile, then developing countries should be like a house of cards. Interestingly enough, this is not necessarily so. Developed country systems are tightly linked together and are dependent on all parts functioning smoothly. Developing country systems are not so tightly linked together. People living in these systems are more used to fending for themselves simply because the system in which they live is usually dysfunctional to a greater or lesser degree. This also means that in times of need, local communities will rally together simply because they are more attuned to doing so. These systems are thus more robust because they are more primitive. That in a nutshell is the paradox of development: the greater the development, the more tightly linked different parts of the system are, the more fragile the overall system becomes.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

On Development

We are all part of a global society that is obsessed with development. On all media, in all forums and frequently in private conversations, this is an underlying theme. However, development is an abstract concept and people are usually not very good with abstractions. We prefer to deal with more concrete ideas. So the problem is how to visualize development. The route normally taken is to equate development with growth but this only pushes the problem down another level. Growth itself is an abstract concept and so how do we visualize growth?

Development and growth, being abstract concepts, have many dimensions. The solution to the problem of visualizing development and growth is to focus on one or a few of the dimensions. The primary dimension along which development and growth are visualized is material well-being and this is itself visualized by our ease of access to the material things we need to exist. Some of these material things are necessary for us to live. So one measure of development is do we have access to water, food and shelter. These are then refined further. In the case of water, do we draw water from a well? A community tap? Water piped directly into our homes? In the case of food, in what quantity, then quality and then variety? Other material things are not necessary for survival but we deem them to be necessary in order to function effectively in a modern economy. Cases in point: cell phones and electricity in our homes and businesses. Still others are adornments that we decorate our houses and bodies with.

In a sense, this emphasis on materialism is not very surprising. In order to merely survive, we need access to a minimum quantity of resources - material things. In order to function effectively in our economy, we need access to a variety of material resources. The exact composition of the things changes over time. These changes are considered development. So development has essentially boiled down to a numbers game. How many things of different variety do we own irrespective of whether we actually have a use for them or not. There is a heavy, almost exclusive emphasis on materialism. All the measures that we use to monitor development and growth are based on material aspects. Whether we are measuring GDP or productivity or something else, we are seeing how much and hoe quickly can we produce things. Of course what is produced also needs to be consumed and so development is also increasing consumption of these things. Humans are thus reduced to producing and consuming automatons fascinated with shiny baubles and trinkets. In many respects, materialism makes us behave like the proverbial native Americans who gave up Manhattan island for a few cheap, shiny baubles.

Is there any harm in this? This emphasis on materialism has produced wonders for us. A large number of people today live in a style and comfort that even kings of bygone eras could not have dreamed of. Even the poorest of us have access to a level of goods and services that at one time would have been considered luxurious. By these measures, materialism has been good. So there's no problem there right? Not quite. To a considerable extent, we are what we measure. In other words, we become the dimensions of our existence that we emphasize. Materialism is merely one aspect of development. There are many other dimensions. How are we developing as individuals? How are we developing as a community? What kind of a culture or legacy are we bequeathing to later generations? Will we be remembered for our strange fascination with baubles and trinkets or will we be remembered for our music, our words that we leave behind, the social structures that we evolve? What about our spiritual side? What about our emotional side? Many of us are mental and emotional wrecks. These are symptoms brought about by the stresses of modern life. How do these stresses arise? Through an emphasis on materialism. Has material development made us happier, more mature, more fulfilled? Is our global culture producing enduring cultural and literary works? Or are we producing works that will barely be remembered a generation hence. What measures are truly important to focus on when we say development?
Enhanced by Zemanta