Showing posts with label Business and Economy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Business and Economy. Show all posts

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Copyright Issues

Copyrights, patents, trademarks have become contentious issues in a modern, increasingly digitized world. Copyright first became an issue with the invention of the movable type printing press. Previously, it was a non-issue because of the slow speed of manually copying a book and the lack of literacy amongst the general population. The printing press changed the equation by drastically reducing the cost of and time taken to copy a book. It also resulted in a gradual increase in literacy as people started seeing the advantages of being able to read. A good history of copyright can be found at the Copyright History website and also at Wikipedia.

Copyrights were originally seen as an incentive for creative artists. The idea was that they would have a limited time in which they could exploit their created work for commercial gain after which the work would be available in the public domain for anyone to do with it as they please. Copyrights and patents thus served a dual purpose. They were an incentive for creative people to be creative and to create new works and products. The second purpose was that once the work went out of copyright or patent protection into the public domain, the nation's cultural heritage would be enriched and succeeding generations would have a richer, more diverse heritage to build upon. Many of the cultural icons in most societies, specially Western ones, are as such because the original work either went out of copyright or the copyright holder did not strictly enforce his rights. Not just the local culture, but also the global culture is thus richer as a result.

The situation today is different. The value of enforcing copyrights and patents has increased dramatically. Not only that, but copyrights are increasingly being held by organizations and not by individuals. What is good for the organization is not necessarily good for the culture as a whole. What makes the matter worse is that copyright (and patent) enforcement frequently results in increased charges to the end consumer. When payments are tried to be collected globally, the product usually goes out of the reach of most consumers in developing countries who do not have the financial power of consumers in the developed countries. Sometimes, these attempts at rent collection results in consumers being left physically worse than before.

I'll give an example here. The example is the patents held by Western pharmaceutical companies on existing AIDS medication. While these medicines do not cure the disease, they do enable AIDS sufferers to lead relatively long, productive lives. These medicines are also priced at a level that Western consumers can (barely) pay. As a result, nearly the entire developing world cannot afford to buy them. Even governments in developing countries cannot afford to these medications due to their high cost. Millions of people are thus left to suffer a significantly lower quality of life. When developing world governments in desperation turned towards generic medicines, the Western pharmaceutical companies tried to prevent them from doing so backed by the full might of their national government (specifically the US). It was only a global and specially Western public backlash that forced these companies to back down. Their counter-offer was to reduce the price of these drugs by 90%. Unfortunately, the price was still significantly higher than the price being offered by generic manufacturers. What galls people in the developing world is that when the developed nations have what they perceive as a crisis, they suspend the rules for themselves that they impose on less powerful nations. When the US was faced with the possibility of the Swine Flu spreading dramatically, they threatened to break the patent of the manufacturer of the only drug, Tamiflu, that was effective against this disease. Previously, when a developing country had threatened to break the AIDS patent, the US government had weighed in on the issue in support of the patent holder. The life of a person in the developing world is not worth the same as the life of a person in the developed world. This is seen as rank hypocrisy in the rest of the world. One rule for the developed nations and another for the rest of the world.

Today the original intention of copyrights and patents has been hijacked. This has been done due to their increasingly lucrative nature. Since organizations hold most copyrights and patents, they have an incentive to have the time under protection extended to the maximum possible extent. That is why in the US, the period of copyright protection has increased over time till now it is over 100 years. The question is why should any organization or person be allowed to enjoy this protection for so long.

A case for extended copyright protection can be made for individuals - specially in cases where one work or a small number of works account for the bulk of an individual's creative output. If a songwriter has a single hit in his/her lifetime, then there is a strong case that he/she should enjoy copyright protection for the duration of his/her life. However, should this protection be enjoyed by the children? Why? Ofcourse a case for this also can be made. After all, children do inherit property and enjoy the benefits thereof even though they may have done nothing personally to obtain the property. But then the question in this case becomes should copyrights and patents be treated in the same fashion as say land is? If yes, then no creative work will come into the public domain and cultural heritage will be significantly poorer as a result. So a strong argument can be made that copyrights should be limited in time to the life of an individual.

What about organizations? Unlike a person, the potential lifespan of an organization is unlimited. Should a copyright or patent held by an organization then be under protection for the lifespan of the organization? Effectively this is what organizations are aiming for when they push for extensions of copyright and patent protection. In some cases, the costs to society are viewed as being so great that this effort is resisted. Thus patent protection for medicines is allowed to expire after a set period of time because this is seen as a net benefit to society as a whole. In other cases, the issue is not so clear cut. Take the case of the operating system OS/2 which is owned by IBM. The company has stopped selling this software and seemingly has no plans to re-introduce it. This is seen by their efforts to move existing customers of OS/2 to other operating system. In such a case, should IBM be forced to move OS/2 into the public domain? If OS/2 is moved into the public domain (and in this case moving into the public domain means putting the source code into the public domain), then either other people will start tinkering with it or they will ignore it. However, this will be a choice exercised by society. In the current scenario, this choice cannot be exercised because IBM refuses to allow other people to tinker with OS/2 thereby behaving rather like the proverbial dog in the manger. If other people are allowed to tinker with it, then who knows, they may produce something superior to current offerings. This did happen in the browser market. After Netscape collapsed, some enthusiasts got together and started developing Firefox based on Netscape. In the process, they re-ignited developments in the browser market which had stagnated as a result of the virtual monopoly exercised by Internet Explorer.

On the whole, I feel that there is a strong societal benefit having strictly temporary copyright and patent protections. The term should be long enough to give the original owner reasonable time to enjoy the benefits of his/her creation. Afterwords, the work should be moved into the public domain. The term of protection shoudl vary with the industry. To give examples, pharmaceutical companies need a relatively long time frame because of a long testing phase and an almost equally long regulatory process. Creative works like books, songs, articles etc. should enjoy protection for the lifetime of the original creator but no longer. The benefit to society outweighs the benefits that would accrue to the children. For software, protection should be afforded for a fairly limited period like say 10 years or as long as the product is commercially available whichever is shorter. Generally, a piece of software is no longer commercially available within 5 years of its introduction. Even if the software is made available, its undergoes frequent revisions and later versions bear next to no resemblance to the original version. The point is that a reasonable balance needs to be struck between private interests and societal interests.

Friday, February 13, 2009

A Delusional State

The world has been living in a state of delusion for a long time now. It is now payback time for the excesses of the last several decades. The delusion was that the world can be endlessly exploited without thought of consequences. The growth of consumerism as a leading global ideology has contributed enormously to this delusional mindset. Modern capitalism has both driven and is being driven by consumerism. Short term financial thinking and an emphasis on the bottom line has led companies to try and condition people into equating personal happiness with consumption and the purchase of material possessions in general and their own specific product in particular. Take virtually any advertisement and you will see this element at work. To take an example: I recently saw an ad for a fridge which showed a glamorous woman behaving excitedly and dancing with joy around it. There was no mention of the specific characteristics of the product itself; why should anyone buy it, what made this brand superior to others, what specific benefits did this brand deliver that others did not or if they did in what fashion were these benefits superior to the offerings of competitors? None of these questions were addressed by the ad. Instead the focus was on convincing viewers that purchase of this particular brand would make them feel better or enhance their status. To take another example: you see people wearing branded shirts and the like. Sometimes these have messages written on them. Generally these messages aim to amuse or shock. If you see the ads for such clothing, the message will emphasize how this particular item will help a person express his or her unique individuality. Yet there will be several thousand people (at the very least) who will be wearing such clothes.

It is this equating of personal happiness and consumption that drives the current model of capitalism. If consumers are not made to feel that they have to buy items which they generally do not require, then the whole edifice starts coming down. The result was that consumers in the developed countries ended up with massive debts and this debt fueled consumption model was exported around the world. Now, however, the credit crunch has exposed the limitations of this model. It seems that this method of business has reached its limits and a painful period of adjustment has started.
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Collapse of the Washington Consensus

Milton Friedman must be rolling over in his grave. The economic ideas he espoused throughout his life have imploded in a spectacular fashion. Keynesianism which he derided has thus far withstood the test of time. Friedman's ideas were packaged to the world as part of the Washington Consensus.

"Washington Consensus" as a term was first coined by an economist working in the Institute of International Economics. It proposed ten recommendations which were:
  1. Fiscal policy discipline.
  2. Redirection of public spending from subsidies (specially those defined as indiscriminate) towards provision of pro-poor, pro-growth policies like primary education, primary health care and infrastructure development.
  3. Tax reform aimed at broadening the tax base and reducing the marginal tax rate to "moderate" levels.
  4. Market determined interest rates.
  5. Competitive exchange rates.
  6. Trade liberalization.
  7. Liberalization of inward foreign direct investment.
  8. Privatization of state enterprises.
  9. Deregulation i.e. abolition of regulations that impede market entry or restrict competition.
  10. Legal security of property rights.
These policies were strongly supported by international financial institutions like the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. However, these proposals degenerated quite rapidly into market fundamentalism. The key characteristic of market fundamentalism is a strong, indeed dogmatic belief that markets tend towards a natural equilibrium and the best interests in a society "are achieved by allowing its participants to pursue their own self interest" (Wikipedia definition).

There are a few assumptions at play in both points of view and in market fundamentalism in particular. First of all, the fundamental assumption in the belief in the efficacy of markets is the assumption that conditions of perfect competition exist in all cases. Perfect competition assumes that there are no barriers to entry and exit, buyers and sellers have equal (and perfect) information and both parties have the same (or at least similar) economic power. These are all highly unrealistic assumptions. There is no market in the world where these conditions apply. The nearest approximation we come to are the stock exchanges and even there not all the assumptions hold true.

There is another problem with market fundamentalism. It assumes that everyone is either a buyer or a seller and that all buyers and sellers find each other. In other words, markets will find their own level of employment which may or may not correspond to full employment although the underlying assumption is that this will result in full employment. People who cannot play either role are ignored and under conditions of perfect market fundamentalism will be left to their own devices. The implicit assumption here is that buyers and sellers have access to the same amount of information regarding the transaction.

Friedman advocated a set of policies that have proven to be deeply unpopular everywhere. Furthermore, they have failed repeatedly in country after country where they were imposed. Take two test cases: Chile and Argentina.

Chile was the first country where the full weight of the Washington consensus and market fundamentalism was imposed. The country's murderous ruler Pinochet was assured that imposing these policies would result in short term pain but long term gain. How short is short term? The answer given was in months. The reality proved to be somewhat different. The downturn lasted several years instead of the promised months. A large number of people were thrown out of work. Poverty increased sharply along with income inequality. The local business community which had strongly supported the coup found itself at a severe disadvantage vis-a-vis foreign competitors for whom the economy was thrown wide open. Government revenues collapsed. The promised utopia never arrived. Instead, after a few years, the government found itself nationalizing the entire banking sector to save it from complete collapse.

Argentina was a similar case. To a greater extent than Chile, the country was a poster child for the IMF. This is the one country which followed the dicates of the consensus and market fundamentalism faithfully. The result was repeated economic collapse. In the nineties, the government went to a much further extent than previously in following the dictates of the IMF. For several years, Argentina was touted as a success story. This was a country which had become lean and mean. A country which had laid the foundations for long term success. And then the whole edifice came crumbling down. The foundations turned out to be built of sand. Economic growth was only achieved after Argentina defaulted on its debts and repudiated the recommendations of the IMF.

The 1997 Asian crisis too was a result of the consensus and market fundamentalism. Under pressure from the World Bank and the IMF, the Asian tigers loosened capital controls allowing so called hot money to come roaring in. For some time all was hunky dory. Foreign capital flowed in and massive investments were made in different sectors specially real estate. Then a rumour started concerning economic weakness regarding Thailand and suddenly all the hot money that had come roaring in was abruptly yanked out leaving economic devastation in its wake. The countries that were not affected were those which had resisted the pressure to loosen capital controls. Amongst the tigers, the one exception was Malaysia which rejected IMF advice and imposed capital controls. Other countries accepted IMF's advice and suffered from massive downturns. By contrast, the downturn in Malaysia was shallower and growth resumed more quickly and at a faster pace as compared to the other tigers.

Look at the situation today. The global financial system faces collapse and threatens to take the global economy down with it. In each and every case, markets have completely failed to find their equilibrium. Even Alan Greenspan has recently admitted the failure of the self regulating markets paradigm. Again it boils down to the assumptions made by market fundamentalism. Economics assumes conditions of perfect competition in order to make analysis of supply and demand easier. However, real world markets do not behave like this. Especially under free market fundamentalism, the effect of unfettered competition is actually to increase concentration and reduce consumer choice as larger firms swallow smaller ones. This increased concentration results in asymmetric information. Buyers generally do not have the amount of information that sellers have. This results in greater power accruing to the seller. As various scandals over the years have shown, such power is inevitably abused.

The financial crisis of 2008 has shown that the set of policies advocated by Friedman and the market fundamentalists results in an economic disaster of massive proportions. The policies taken to combat this crisis are in direct contradiction to those of the consensus and are more in line with those of Keynes. Thirty years of market fundamentalism have shown the economic philosophy (if it can be called that) to be a house of cards which cannot withstand the test of time.